Beau Scott apparent "automatic selection"...WHY?

Yeah there are some players that are consider auto selctions despite being average players like bird, gallen, pearce I think that ppl tend to base their opinion on good players on what other people think are good players ppl commenators mainly, I mean if ppl here commenatators say he should be in origin then ppl assume he is better than the rest of the players in the country at that position